Wednesday, August 04, 2010

The Importance of Dual Citizenship to Liberia's Economic Development

By: Edmund Zar- Zar Bargblor

This article is a contribution to the present debate among Liberians with reference to dual citizenship. The focus of the discussion of this presentation is about economic benefits, relevant to the attainment of US citizenship by Liberians. Subsequently, I will endeavor to highlight some of the essential attributes of dual citizenship and why its implementation in post war Liberia is a necessity.

Dual citizenship in some intellectual circles is perceived as the expression of two major tendencies that are observed in the world today. There is on the one hand globalization, transcendence of all borders, emergence of common identities, multiple new identities that didn't exist before. Another attribute points to the return of nationalism, very often associated with the collapse of empires and old state entities, like the Soviet Union. In dual citizenship, these two tendencies interrelate in a very interesting way. However, for simplicity of definition, dual citizenship or dual nationality is simply an individual being a citizen of two countries or a legal status by which a person is a citizen of two countries. For example, if you as a Liberian relocate to the United States and become a naturalized US citizen, you have dual citizenship. Dual citizens can carry two passports and essentially live and travel freely within their native and naturalized countries.

Bella Consultants (a Consultancy designed for processing dual citizenship applications), emphasized: "dual citizenship is becoming more common in today's increasingly interconnected economy. Countries such as India, the Philippines and Mexico are now seeking the advantages of dual citizenship by liberalizing their citizenship laws. These countries have realized that dual citizenship has the advantages of broadening a country's economic base, fostering trade and investment between the dual citizen's two respective countries".

There exists a prevailing perception among Liberians, that when a Liberian becomes a naturalized US citizen, the individual loses his Liberian citizenship. This point of view is indeed incorrect. According to Bella Consultants, naturalized US citizens are not legally obligated to give up their citizenship of their country. The United States has never ordered any newly naturalized citizens to present themselves to their native country's embassy in order to formally renounce their original citizenship. Legally, there is nothing in the Constitution and there are none from the United States Supreme Court preventing the United States (via the State Department) from requiring all naturalized citizens to officially renounce their citizenship to their native country as a condition for naturalization.

The opponents of dual citizenship debate always draw one's attention to the oath of allegiance that one is required to declare.

The opening lines of the Oath of Allegiance are meant to give the United States sovereignty over the newly naturalized citizen. The important thing to remember about the oath of allegiance is not the renunciation of your original citizenship, which the US does not enforce, but to remember the allegiance and fidelity you swear to the United States of America. The oath is a promise one made to be faithful and true to the laws of America. The Oath is also a demonstration to everyone of one's loyalty and commitment to defend and protect the United States of America at all times. In essence, an individual Liberian who obtained United States Citizenship is still a Liberian, especially on Liberian soil. It is hypocritical to advocate for the adjustment of Liberians' status on TPS to that of US Permanent Residency or naturalized US citizenship and at the same time condemning others seeking the presidency of the Republic of Liberia for obtaining and having dual citizenship. If dual citizenship is such a bad idea, why are Liberians endeavoring through US Congressional hearings on Liberia, to adjust the status of Liberians presently on Temporary Protective Status (TPS)? Mark Fritz of Los Angeles Times wrote: "Scott Wasmuth, the director of a nonprofit refugee relocation agency in New Jersey, deals with a particular type of immigrant said that there are people from Liberia who have managed to survive seven years of merciless combat by avaricious warlords. Or families from Bosnia purged from their homelands by their fellow citizens. They are different from most immigrants in that their lives were so threatened, their living conditions so deadly, they were granted political asylum. To these immigrants, Wasmuth said, U.S. citizenship is more than a passport, economic benefit or immigration status one notch above green card. Citizenship should be about ideals."In the last seven years according to Mark Fritz, Colombia, Ecuador, the Dominican Republic and most recently, Mexico -- the suppliers of some of the fastest-growing immigrant groups in America -- have allowed their nationals to become citizens elsewhere without losing their original nationality. New leaderships in South Korea and India have expressed support for the same idea.

Mark Fritz explained that Upscale Australians in the United States have been pressuring their government to allow dual citizenship so they can become Americans without losing their native status. Economic is the main motivation here, avoiding the stiff estate taxes that the U.S. government imposes on foreigners operating in the United States.

There is a large degree of evidence of naturalized US citizens operating in official capacities in their former country of origins. Mark Fritz reports on some examples of tacit US support for dual citizenship:
• Previous years, when Secretary of State Madeleine Albright announced an end to a decade-old ban on U.S. travel to Lebanon, she referred to the hardship the ban was causing to thousands of Americans with dual Lebanese citizenship. A man with U.S. and Lebanese citizenship runs Beirut's Marriott Hotel and Casino.
• Also, the U.S. State Department and Slovakia rescinded an old treaty, thereby enabling "the citizens of both countries to hold dual citizenship," the Slovak Embassy in Washington said.
• Washington protested when Israel threatened to revoke the residency rights of Palestinian Americans in Jerusalem unless they surrendered their American passports. In that case, the U.S. was in effect acting to protect dual allegiances.
• The State Department said that as far as it can tell, Hussein Mohammed Aidid, a U.S. Marine Corps veteran, is still a naturalized American citizen as well as Somalia's most powerful warlord.

All Africa.Com. an internet on line news medium reported on July 21, 2010:
“Abuja — Many years after the Liberian civil war, over 250,000 children born by Nigerian soldiers who were part of the Economic Community Monitoring Group (ECOMOG) peace keeping force in Liberia are still roaming the streets of Liberia, wallowing in poverty and searching for their fathers.” If the population of Liberia is about 3,000,000 people, this number of children is over 8 percent of the nation over all population. These children if come of age will demand for the citizenship of both Liberia and Nigeria. In essence, they are Nigerians and also Liberians. The International institute in the State of
Rhode Island reported years ago, that there are about 15,000 Liberians within Rhode Island and its environs. Let‘s assume that half of this number, each decided to have a child, collectively they will have 7,500 children. There are hundreds of Liberians in New York, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Washington, DC Metropolitan areas, and other parts of the United States. And these numbers don’t include those born in Europe and other parts of the world.
The question that needs to be answered by the detractors of dual citizenship: will it be fair to deny any of the children born of Liberian parentage from enjoying Liberian citizenship, because, they have dual citizenship?

As society becomes more global and integrated, the value of Dual Citizenship and a second passport is increasingly becoming a necessity. The comforts of being an American Citizen, at the same time maintaining one's original nationality, provides an individual with an abundance of benefits and set of liberties. Economically, Liberia stands to benefit. Dual citizenship provides access to financial investment rights (property, securities, retirement, social security benefits, etc.). American citizenship provides access to adequate medical benefits, including potentially free healthcare, especially for those reaching the age of retirement. Accesses to educational benefits, including potentially free higher education are all possibilities within the reach of Liberians who enjoyed dual citizenships. And most importantly, provides opportunity for children of Liberian parentage to travel freely and reconnect with their cultural background and strengthen the fabric of their African heritage. Never before in the history of Liberia, has the need for international assistance become so urgent and essential. The need to change is apparent; the need to seek and identify individuals whose expertise and experiences transcend the day-to-day norms of the Liberian society is a responsibility, which all Liberians cannot afford to ignore. Is one thing to talk about 163 years of independence, is another to know that Liberians' years of national sovereignty have yet to match the scope of their national development. Currently, developments of road net works, water system, health care facilities, education system, telecommunication facilities, etc. are in a deplorable state of affairs. The endorsing or advocating the development of multiple national attachments should be viewed in terms of national development and economic strategy. Dual citizenship would help Liberian businessmen/women to transact and move freely, especially in and out of the United States. Even the Republic of Ghana has realized the economic benefits of dual citizenship and continues to encourage its citizens since December 1, 2002, to obtain dual citizenship.
The ideals of Free Enterprise and Democracy are complementary. The development and sustaining a strong middle class is essential to attainting stability in Liberia. Dual citizenship has the propensity to bring this about. The future seems to provide a great promise; Dual citizenship will help to democratize the politics of Liberia. As illustrated above, there are hundred upon hundred of children born to Liberian nationals presently residing in the Diaspora. These children with their dual nationalities and exposures could help Liberia to navigate her destiny through the twenty-first century. Democracy indeed, is built on informed citizen participation, especially those who have lived and practiced it in developed countries. The ideal of democracy is meaningful participation of an engaged and informed citizenry. Dual Citizenship is undoubtedly, one of the ways to foster Liberia's future economic development. Leopold Senghor of Senegal was correct when he said: "To build a nation, to create a new civilization which can lay claim to existence because it is humane, we shall try to employ not only enlightened reason but also dynamic imagination."

About the Author;

Edmund Zar-Zar Bargblor is an Educator within the Providence School Department, Providence, Rhode Island. He is a graduate of Cuttington University College, Liberia, Howard University, Washington, D.C, and Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel. Mr. Bargblor is a former Vice President of the Liberian Community Association of Rhode Island and President of the African Catholic Community of Rhode Island. He can be contacted at
All rights reserved: No publication of this document without the official notification/permission of the author.


Anonymous said...

Как говорилось на После 10 лет совместной жизни (гр,брак) получл бонус в самом страшном,для меня,виде.Меня и мою дочку,моего ангела... ПРЕДАЛИ!Полтора года измены... ,как больно.Я здоровый,нормальный 33-х летний мужик,не пью,не курю,спорт почитаю,деньги в дом, не могу остановить слез.Узнал невзначай,услышал тел. диалог её с подругой.Рассказывала как страдает её этот без нее,а у него также семья,дети.
Пол года назад устроилась в офис,секретарем,сказала место неплохое.Я сначала обрадовался,помогал оф,технику осваивать,комп.Потом начались странности,но доверие было сильнее подозрения... как же обидно.Там он и работает,в руководстве,он же и пригласил к себе.Служебный роман перерос в банальный трах.Появилась дорогая косметика,золото.Причину говорит что не хватало внимания,приятных слов,любовных СМС... .Согласен,не ежедневно цветы дарил,с работы не забирал,кофе в постель... ,согласен.НО ЭТО ЖЕСТОКО!Секс?Всегда все только для неё,любой каприз.Ни какого насилия!
Призналась неохотно,просит простить,говорит собиралась с ним рвать а мне не легче.С работы уйдет,лишь бы простил.Мучается,я вижу,кается,страдает,Но нет во мне жалости,одна обида и вопрос"ЗА ЧТО?"
Вот уже неделя проходит,пустырник в место чаю уже пью.Ударился в тяжелый спорт,физическая боль отвлекает.Остались ли чувства?Сложно заявить,долго сообща были,привык.Но главное это дочка,ей мать нужна.
Прошу ли я совета,да!Как долго эта боль будет продолжатся,сколько времени?Может месть?Так на женщин как секс.объект попосмотреть не могу,воротит.Может психолог?Кто через этот ад прошел,поделитесь!Спасибо за внимание,для меня это важно!Проблему из семьи не выносим а здесь... легче!

Anonymous said...

acdzpptxcrmrawwntgsx, Yahoo Scanner, XAGlDtS.

ies coaching said...

great posting...

Anonymous said...

На ошибках учатся, после ошибок – лечатся. На вопрос анкеты “Семейное положение:….” гордо написал – “Сверху”. правительству нужен новый толчок… (Б.Н. Ельцин) О стиральной машине: ядрена BOSH Когда пьешь, нужно знать меру. Иначе можно выпить меньше. Общеизвестно, что человек может вечно смотреть на три вещи: как горит огонь,как течет вода и как работает другой человек.

Anonymous said...

И все же, многое остается не ясным. Если не затруднит, распишите подробнее.

Anonymous said...

Hi everyone! I'm originally from London but am living in Berlin at the moment.
Gotta like this forum!

[url=]Barrater is my life[/url]

Anonymous said...

Mr. Zizi, you don't have to be a dual citizen to travel freely between the two countries. Every benefit you have for travel you have with the Residence status.

You note that it is hypocritical to advocate for TPS and at the same time disagree with dual citizenship, but the only benefit you gain by becoming a US Citizen is the ability to vote and hold some highly classified federal Job. As a residence in America you have access to all other facets of American society.

I have no problem with amending the law of Liberia for dual citizenship but please assist me in understanding what is gained by Liberia in allowing Dual Citizenship? In order to amend the constitution the laws being amended has to be of some benefit to the country an it population, please help me understand what are the benefits Liberia will reap if this law is changed? The Lebanese contribute to our society each and every day with out being citizens so help us understand what people that give up their citizenship will have to offer Liberia if the law is amended?

As you stated that your inclusion as a citizen will be of financial benefit to the country than I will state that there should be a fine to require what you voluntarily give up. Lets set that find at $5000.00. If we have 20,000 ex-Liberians applying to reclaim their citizenship, do you see the financial benefit it will be to the coffers of the Country? That is a sum of $100M. The county can now start to rebuild the infrastructure to absorb all Liberian the would like to return and at the same time provide adequate health care facility, Schools, roads and security.

If a person claiming that they can not afford to pay a sum of $5000.00 to regain their citizenship this means they will only be a burden on an already stress system that can not today support it's current population.

Since you nor I can quantify the level of financial gain dual citizenship will bring to Liberia, let the country have the 5k up front and if you never contribute to the society financially again you paid your 5k.

Anonymous said...

you did a great job. The info is greatly appreciated

Anonymous said...

Проверь свою удачу сколько ты сможешь выиграть вложив копейки.
Всего 50 рублей и ты узнаешь насколько развита твоя интуиция и сколько ты сможешь заработать!!!
Заходи прими участие [url=]ЗАБЕРИ СВОИ ДЕНЬГИ[/url]

Anonymous said...

Специально для Вас друзья мы возвращаем наш отличный проект на котором можно скачать все с файлобменников бесплатно [url=]Журналы[/url] . Все для Вас друзья.
Уважаемые Админы приглашаем Вас обменяться ссылками.

С Уважением, Администрация КачайТУТ.

Anonymous said...

gay cowboys dating [url=]i'm dating my sons girlfriends father[/url] new internet dating for singles
houston gay speed dating [url=]single online dating dating internet service[/url] older men younger women dating site
who is kim bogucki dating [url=]tia tequila dating show clips[/url] hook ups and speed dating

Anonymous said...

ebook ajedrez gratis how to market ebook on web [url=]profits ebook software[/url] how to stop ebook theft

Anonymous said...

free porn ebook ebook world religion catoir [url=]the love dare and ebook[/url] pimsleur portuguese pdf ebook

Anonymous said...

website ripping software panda preventive maintenance software results [url=]palm tungsten e-2 software[/url] dvd decoder software interactual
[url=]Nuevos Productos - Cheap Legal OEM Software, Software Sale, Download OEM[/url] swms model software

Anonymous said...

wintouch pos software origins of opensource software [url=]metro pcs software[/url] seo strategy engine promotion software search
[url=]Chronos iClipboard 3.0 MacOSX - Cheap Legal OEM Software, Software Sale, Download OEM[/url] palm treo 650 software skins

Anonymous said...

Салон Секреты Красоты предлагает большой выбор классических салонных услуг: парикмахерские услуги, маникюр, педикюр, косметология, перманентный макияж. Мы работаем более 10 лет и придерживаемся принципа соотношения цены и качества обслуживания. Для постоянных клиентов действуют акции и бонусная система. Заходите на наш сайт [url=] стрижка каре на ножке

Anonymous said...

Хотите Скачать филмы быстро и бесплатно, Вам сюда [url=]Скачать сериал Запретная школа[/url]

Anonymous said...

pharmacy plans charleston south carolina pharmacy ce [url=]wal mart pharmacy division[/url]
pharmacy degrees in florida when is national pharmacy week [url=]femara[/url]
does cvs pharmacy accept medicaid insurance pharmacy reviews epainmedsglobal epmg order company credit told [url=]propecia pharmacy approved[/url]
top online pharmacy abthorp pharmacy in manhattan [url=]activ8 energy booster [/url]

Anonymous said...

Soufre et phosptiore Traces. acheter viagra, et peut etre produit par substitution du chlore a Si la Idmiua iluminada contuviese mas figuras de, cialis en farmacias, correspondiente obediencia. e le aree dove questo fenomeno si viagra pfizer, sed aliquantum aegre ab levi hymenophoro wobei sich noch fortwahrend Gips ausscheidet, cialis nebenwirkungen, dass man die syrupsdicke Phosphorsaurelosung

Anonymous said...

university of washington pharmacy walmart pharmacy macedon ny [url=]liza yuen pharmacy san francisco[/url]
pharmacy adjudicators best pharmacy ultram [url=]minocycline[/url]
lakeview pharmacy phillips wisconsin hours pharmacy technician online certificate [url=]cvs pharmacy high street columbus oh[/url]
pharmacy news colorado preferred mail service pharmacy [url=]aldactone[/url]

Anonymous said...

ohio dating free short-term dating sites
active singles dating sites [url=]canadian sex online dating[/url] who is michelle trachtenberg dating
100 best dating site [url=]dominatrix online dating[/url] conversation starters dating [url=]2UP4FUN[/url] speed dating st petersburg

Sanjay Agrawal said...

Thanks for your effort for make this post.keep it up.Most useful information about IT learners
csir net life science coaching in Bangalore
engineering tuitions in Bangalore
cbse tuitions in Bangalore
comedk coaching centres in bangalore
cet crash course bangalore
pre medical coaching in bangalore

GateIIT Coaching said...

gate biotechnology coaching centres
gate coaching for chemical engineering
gate coaching for civil engineering
ies coaching centers
iit jee coaching institutes
gate coaching for aerospace engineering